Members CMS
PHP 8.1+ & MySQL Buy license · $349.95
Promotions & statistics

Promotions inside the members area that members don't mind

Members are your warmest audience. How to place cross-sells, upsells and offers, target them by category, weight them and judge them by click rate.

Updated 4 minute read The Members CMS team

Members are the warmest audience you will ever have. They have already trusted you with a payment, they like your content, and they come back regularly. If you run more than one website, or offer upgrades, there is no better place to mention them than inside the members area. The catch is that members are paying for content, not adverts. Promotions that get in the way, repeat endlessly or have nothing to do with what the member enjoys quickly become an annoyance.

This guide covers how to place promotions so they sit comfortably beside the content, how to target and weight them, and how to judge whether they work.

Three kinds of promotion

Most members area promotions fall into one of three types. Knowing which one you are running helps you choose where it goes and who should see it.

TypeWhat it offersExample
Cross-sellAnother website or product you ownA travel photography site promoted to members of your hiking site
UpsellMore of what the member already hasA longer plan or a premium tier
OfferA special deal, such as a seasonal oneA holiday deal on a sister site

For a closer look at the first two, see our guide to upsells vs cross-sells on membership sites.

Placement: beside the content, never in front of it

The quickest way to make members resent promotions is to put them between the member and what they came for. Pop-ups over a gallery, banners that push a video down the page or adverts in the middle of a story all feel like an obstacle. Better places include:

  • The members home page, where members land and look around.
  • Beside or below a gallery, once the member has seen the pictures.
  • The end of a story, when the reader has finished and is deciding what to do next.
  • List pages, such as the galleries or movies list, where a promotion can sit alongside the items.

Use a good picture for each promotion. A strong image from the site being promoted says more than a block of text, and it looks like part of the members area rather than an advert dropped in from elsewhere.

Relevance: target by category

A promotion works best when it matches what the member is already enjoying. A member browsing mountain walks is far more likely to click on a promotion for your landscape photography site than for your baking site. Targeting by category lets the members area show each promotion where it fits.

  1. Give each promotion the categories it suits, for example Outdoors and Landscapes for the photography site.
  2. Choose which websites it may appear on.
  3. Never cross-sell a site to its own members. Someone already inside your cooking site does not need an advert for it.

Your statistics can guide targeting. If members of one site show strong interest in a category that a sister site specialises in, that pairing is worth promoting. Category demand figures, shown as views per item, are a good way to spot it.

Frequency: weights and dates

If you have several promotions that could appear in the same place, you need a way to decide how often each one shows. Weighting does this: a promotion with a higher weight is shown more often than one with a lower weight. Give your best-performing or most important promotion the highest weight, and let others appear less often so members do not see the same thing on every page.

Start and end dates keep promotions tidy. A seasonal offer should stop appearing when the season ends, and a promotion for a site you are launching should start on launch day. Setting dates up front means nothing lingers after it has stopped being true, which protects members' trust. For an offer with a genuine deadline, see our guide to running honest timed offers.

Weights are not the only tool. A priority decides which promotion wins when several compete, and a conflict group makes sure only one promotion from a group appears in a placement. Our guide to stopping competing promotions showing together explains both.

Measuring what works

Every promotion should be judged on numbers, not hunches. Three figures matter:

  • Views - how many times the promotion was shown.
  • Clicks - how many times members clicked it.
  • Click rate - clicks divided by views, which lets you compare promotions shown different numbers of times.

Click rate shows interest, not sales. A click means the member wanted to know more; whether they then bought is something to check in your billing processor's reports. Compare the two now and then: a promotion with a high click rate but few sales may need a clearer landing page, while one with a modest click rate and strong sales is worth a higher weight. For the wider picture, see members area statistics worth tracking.

How Members CMS handles this

Members CMS lets you manage promotions for all your members areas from Members Areas > Promotions. Each promotion is a cross-sell, upsell or offer, with an image chosen from your library, a placement on the page, the websites it may appear on, start and end dates, a weight that sets how often it shows relative to others, and target categories. A cross-sell is never shown on the site it promotes. Promotions can also have a priority, belong to a conflict group, follow promotional rules and rotate on their own schedules, and upsells and cross-sells can run as timed offers with a real expiry and an honest countdown.

Members CMS reports views, clicks and click rate for every promotion, so you can see which ones members respond to and adjust weights and targeting accordingly. Sales stay with your billing processor, which remains the place to count them.

Frequently asked questions

Where should promotions go in a members area?

Places that don't block the content, such as beside or below galleries and stories, or on the members home page.

How do weights work?

A promotion with a higher weight is shown more often than one with a lower weight when both could appear in the same place.

Is a click a sale?

No. Click rate shows interest. Count sales with your billing processor's reports.

Get three guides like this every month, plus software update notices.Subscribe →