Once you have more than a handful of promotions, they start getting in each other's way. Two discounts on the same upgrade appear side by side. A member sees a "20% off" banner next to a "30% off" banner and wonders which is real. A sister site is promoted to members who are already on it. None of this is deliberate, it simply happens when several promotions are eligible for the same spot and nothing decides between them.
The fix is a small set of rules that decide which promotions may appear together, which one wins when they compete, and how often each can be shown. This guide explains those rules in plain terms.
Why competing promotions cause problems
When promotions clash, members lose confidence. If two offers for the same product show different prices, at least one of them looks wrong. If three different upgrade banners appear on one page, none of them stands out. And if a member clicks the smaller discount when a bigger one was available, they may feel cheated when they find out later.
Clashes usually come from a few sources:
- Two offers for the same product running in overlapping dates.
- A general upgrade promotion and a timed discount on the same upgrade.
- Several cross-sells for closely related sites competing for one slot.
- A cross-sell for the very site the member is already on.
Conflict groups: only one per placement
A conflict group is a set of promotions that should never appear together. You might create a group called "Yearly upgrade offers" and put every promotion for the yearly plan in it, whether it is the standard upgrade banner, a spring discount or an anniversary offer.
When several promotions from the same group are eligible for one placement, only one is chosen. The others wait for another day or another placement. The member sees one clear offer for the yearly plan instead of three slightly different ones.
Choosing good groups
- Group promotions that sell the same thing, such as the same tier or the same sister site.
- Group promotions that would contradict each other, such as two different prices.
- Keep groups small and clearly named so you can see at a glance why something didn't show.
Deciding the winner
When promotions compete, something has to choose between them. Common methods are:
| Method | How it chooses | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| Highest priority | The promotion you ranked highest wins | A key offer you always want shown first |
| Most relevant | The best category match with the site wins | Cross-sells on niche sites |
| Oldest last displayed | The one shown least recently wins | Sharing exposure fairly |
| Random | Any eligible promotion may win | Simple variety |
| Weighted | Higher-weighted promotions win more often | Favouring some without hiding others |
Priority is usually the safest starting point. A timed discount with a genuine deadline can be given a higher priority than the standard upgrade banner, so it wins while it runs and the standard banner returns once it ends. Our guide on running honest timed offers explains how to set real start and end times.
Other rules that keep things tidy
Self-promotion exclusions
A website should not show a cross-sell for itself. A self-promotion exclusion makes sure the Puppy Obedience Club site never cross-sells Puppy Obedience Club, even if that promotion matches its categories perfectly.
Website and category exclusions
Some promotions don't belong on some sites. Excluding a website, or a category, keeps a promotion away from places where it would look out of place, however well it matches otherwise.
Placement restrictions
A promotion designed as a wide banner may look wrong in a narrow sidebar. Restricting it to suitable placements avoids awkward layouts.
Cooldowns
A cooldown sets the minimum time before the same promotion can be shown again in the same place. This stops one offer dominating and gives others a turn. It works hand in hand with rotating promotions on a schedule.
Minimum relevance
Requiring a minimum number of matching categories means a promotion only appears where it genuinely fits. If nothing relevant is available, it is better to show nothing than to show something unrelated.
Checking your rules work
Rules are only useful if they do what you expect. After setting them up:
- Look at each website and list which promotions are eligible for each placement.
- Check that no two promotions from the same conflict group can appear together.
- Confirm that no site is cross-selling itself.
- Look again whenever you add a new promotion or a new website.
Promotions also follow the same broad thinking as content: a promotion that doesn't suit a site is a bit like content in the wrong category. The guide on upsells vs cross-sells covers where each kind of promotion fits best.
How Members CMS handles this
Members CMS has a Promotions menu with Conflict Groups and Promotional Rules screens. Rules include website and category exclusions, conflict groups (only one promotion from a group per placement), priority, placement restrictions, cooldowns, scheduling, minimum relevance and self-promotion exclusions. Winners can be chosen by highest priority, most relevance, oldest last displayed, random or weighted rotation, and the same promotion never appears twice in one placement. The winners are shown in each website's members area through the connector, and Members CMS reports views, clicks and click rate for every promotion, so you can see how they perform.
Exclusions based on what a member already owns will only be possible once real membership data is connected. Until then, Members CMS does not guess.
Frequently asked questions
What is a conflict group?
A set of promotions that should never appear together. When several from the same group are eligible for one spot, only one is chosen.
How is the winner chosen?
By the rules you set, such as highest priority, most relevant, the one shown least recently, random or weighted rotation.
Should a site promote itself?
Usually not as a cross-sell. Self-promotion exclusions stop a website showing a cross-sell for the site the member is already on.
