Most membership sites have more to offer a member than the membership they joined with. There may be a higher tier, a longer plan, a bonus package, or a sister site with related content. The question is how to put those offers in front of members without turning the members area into a wall of adverts.
Two terms come up again and again: upsells and cross-sells. They sound similar, but they do different jobs, suit different places on a site and need slightly different rules. Getting the difference clear makes it much easier to decide what to show, where and to whom.
The difference in one sentence
An upsell offers the member more of what they already have. A cross-sell offers them something different that you also own.
If a member of Puppy Obedience Club is offered a yearly plan instead of a monthly one, that is an upsell. If the same member is offered a membership on your separate Agility Stars site, that is a cross-sell. Both aim to increase what the member gets from you, but the upsell deepens the current relationship while the cross-sell widens it.
| Upsell | Cross-sell | |
|---|---|---|
| What it offers | An upgrade to the current membership | A different product, membership or website |
| Typical examples | Higher tier, longer plan, premium package, add-on service | Sister site, related collection, partner offer you approve |
| Best moment | When the member is getting value from what they have | When the member's interests point beyond the current site |
| Main risk | Feeling pushy if shown too often | Feeling irrelevant if the topic does not match |
Where upsells work on a membership site
Upsells work best when the member has just seen the value of what they are paying for. Someone who has scrolled through a whole gallery or finished a long story is in a good frame of mind to hear about a tier with more of it.
Good places for upsells include:
- The members home page, where members land after signing in.
- Below a gallery or between gallery items, after the member has enjoyed some content.
- Upgrade pages, where the member has already shown interest in more.
- The end of a story or video page.
Keep the message specific. "Upgrade to yearly and get every new set for 12 months" is clearer than a generic "Go premium". Members should understand exactly what changes if they say yes.
Where cross-sells work
Cross-sells depend on relevance. A member who joined a site about puppy obedience may well enjoy a site about recall training, but probably has little interest in a cooking site you also run. The closer the overlap in topics, the better a cross-sell performs and the less it feels like an interruption.
This is where categories help. If your content and your promotions share the same categories, a cross-sell tagged Dogs and Recall can be shown only on sites whose members are interested in those topics. The same tagging that decides which content a site gets can also decide which promotions it gets.
Cross-sells also need one rule upsells don't: a site should not cross-sell itself. Offering a member the site they are already on is wasted space at best and confusing at worst. Our guide to promotions inside the members area that work covers placement and targeting in more detail.
Keeping promotions relevant and restrained
The most common mistake with both types is showing too many. A members area with a banner on every page and three offers in every sidebar teaches members to ignore all of them. A few well-chosen promotions in sensible places do far better.
Practical rules that help
- Limit how many show at once. One or two per placement is usually plenty.
- Match by category. Only show promotions whose topics match the site, and exclude categories that don't belong there.
- Use weights and priorities. When several promotions could fill the same spot, give your most important one a higher weight so it shows more often, or a higher priority so it wins outright.
- Refresh the artwork. The same banner for months becomes invisible. Swap in a new image or new wording now and then, or rotate promotions on a schedule.
- Use real dates. Give each promotion a start and end date that matches the offer, and never pretend an offer is ending when it is not. Our guide to honest timed offers covers countdowns.
Measure carefully
Once you can track how promotions perform, look at views, clicks and click rate, and compare them with the sign-ups and upgrades your billing processor reports. A click shows interest, not a purchase. Treating clicks as sales makes a weak offer look strong and can lead you to show it far more than it deserves. Our guide to members area statistics worth tracking covers the wider picture.
Running upsells and cross-sells across several sites
If you run a network of sites, promotions multiply quickly. Each site may have its own upgrade offers, and every site is a possible cross-sell for the others. Managing banners by hand on each site soon becomes a job of its own, and it is easy to leave an expired offer running on one site or forget to add a new one to another.
A central list of promotions, each with its own websites, target categories, dates, weight and priority, keeps this under control. You update an offer once and every site that uses it follows the same rules.
How Members CMS handles this
Members CMS manages promotions centrally under Members Areas > Promotions and shows them in each website's members area through the connector. There are three types: cross-sell, upsell and offer. Each promotion has an image from your library, a placement on the page, the websites it may appear on, start and end dates, a weight that sets how often it shows relative to others, and target categories, matched by the same engine that decides each site's content.
A cross-sell is never shown on the site it promotes, so no site ends up advertising itself. For every promotion Members CMS reports views, clicks and click rate, so you can see which upsells and cross-sells members actually respond to. Promotions can also have priorities and conflict groups, upsells and cross-sells can rotate on their own schedules, and timed offers carry a real expiry with an honest countdown. Sign-ups and payments stay with your billing processor.
Frequently asked questions
What counts as an upsell on a membership site?
Anything that upgrades what the member already has: a higher membership tier, a premium package, a longer plan or an add-on service.
What counts as a cross-sell?
A different product, membership or website you own that the member might also enjoy, such as a sister site with related content.
Should every page show a promotion?
No. A few relevant promotions in sensible places work better than a promotion everywhere. Use weights, priorities and categories so the most suitable ones show most often.
