Members CMS
PHP 8.1+ & MySQL Buy license · $349.95
Categories & matching

Match ALL, Match ANY or Preferred + Filler: choosing a matching mode

How each category matching mode decides what a website shows, with worked examples, and how to pick the right one for a broad or a niche site.

Updated 4 minute read The Members CMS team

When one content library feeds several websites, each site needs a rule for deciding which items belong to it. You pick the categories the site is about, but there is still a question: does an item need all of those categories, just one of them, or something in between?

That rule is the matching mode. This guide explains the three common modes - Match ALL, Match ANY and Preferred + Filler - with worked examples, and helps you choose the right one for a broad or a niche site.

A worked example to keep in mind

Imagine a website called Puppy Obedience Club. It selects two categories: Puppies and Obedience. Now take five sets from the library:

SetCategoriesShared with site
ADogs, Puppies, Obedience, Tricks2 of 2
BDogs, Puppies, Obedience, Lead Walking2 of 2
CDogs, Puppies, Agility1 of 2
DDogs, Adult Dogs, Obedience1 of 2
EDogs, Adult Dogs, Agility, Recall0 of 2

Let's see what each mode does with these five sets. The examples rely on flat categories, where an item has exactly the categories ticked on it - see flat categories vs category trees for why that matters.

Match ALL

An item must carry every category the site selects. Extra categories on the item are fine; missing ones are not.

Result: A and B match. C, D and E do not.

  • Strength: The most focused results. Everything on the site is exactly on-topic.
  • Weakness: The smallest pool of content. A new or very specific site can run short quickly.
  • Best for: Niche sites with a clear, narrow theme and a healthy supply of exact matches.

Be careful about selecting too many categories in Match ALL mode. Each extra one shrinks the pool further. Choose only the categories that define the site.

Match ANY

An item needs at least one of the site's categories.

Result: A, B, C and D match. Only E does not.

  • Strength: The most content. Great for broad sites.
  • Weakness: A niche site can feel unfocused. Puppy Obedience Club would show puppy agility sets and adult dog obedience sets, which may not be what members signed up for.
  • Best for: Broad, general sites where variety is the point, such as an all-dogs training site selecting Puppies, Adult Dogs and Recall.

Preferred + Filler

This mode sits between the two. Exact matches come first, just as in Match ALL. If the site needs more, it adds partial matches, ranked by how many of the site's categories they share.

Result: A and B first, as exact matches. Then C and D as filler, each sharing one category. E is never used, because it shares none.

Filler is controlled by limits you set, such as:

  • A minimum number of matching categories before an item can count as filler.
  • A maximum filler percentage, so partial matches never outnumber the real thing.
  • Excluded categories, which keep certain content out entirely. Excluding Agility, for example, would remove C from the filler.
  • A rule against repeats, so a filler item is never shown twice just to fill a page.

These limits are covered in detail in filling a niche site without diluting it.

Side by side

Putting the three results together makes the trade-off clear:

ModeSets shownFocusVolume
Match ALLA, BHighestLowest
Preferred + FillerA, B, then C, D within limitsHigh, with controlled extrasMedium
Match ANYA, B, C, D in any orderLowestHighest

The difference between Preferred + Filler and Match ANY can look small in a five-item example, but it grows with the library. Match ANY treats a one-category match the same as a perfect one. Preferred + Filler always puts the perfect ones first and caps how many partial ones can follow, so a niche site keeps its character as more loosely related content arrives.

Choosing the right mode

Your situationSuggested mode
Narrow niche, plenty of exact contentMatch ALL
Narrow niche, not much exact content yetPreferred + Filler with strict limits
Broad site covering several topicsMatch ANY
Broad site, but some topics must stay outMatch ANY plus excluded categories

A few practical tips:

  1. Start with the mode that matches the site's promise to members, then check how much content it produces.
  2. Use exclusions for anything that must never appear, whatever the mode.
  3. Look again once the library grows. A site that needed filler at launch may manage on Match ALL a few months later.
  4. Preview the result before changing a live site's mode, so you can see exactly what will change.

How Members CMS handles this

In Members CMS, every website has its own categories, excluded categories and matching mode, set under Websites > Website Categories and Category Matching Settings. You choose Match ALL, Match ANY or Preferred + Filler for each site. Preferred + Filler shows exact matches first, then partial matches ranked by the number of shared categories, limited by the filler minimum matches and maximum filler percentage across the whole list, and never repeated to fill a page. Exclusions always win, and each site can also limit which content types it takes (sets, stories or both).

Websites > Content Preview gives a live preview and a full paginated preview for each site, so you can try a mode and see the effect before you rely on it. The same matching engine drives the previews, the members areas, the tours and the promotions, so what you see is what members get.

Frequently asked questions

Which mode gives a niche site the most focused content?

Match ALL. An item must carry every category the site selects, so a Puppy Obedience Club site only gets content tagged with all of those categories.

Which mode gives the most content?

Match ANY. An item needs just one of the site's categories, which suits broad sites but can make a niche site feel unfocused.

What does Preferred + Filler do when there isn't enough exact content?

It shows exact matches first, then adds partial matches ranked by how many categories they share, within the minimum match and maximum filler percentage you set.

Get three guides like this every month, plus software update notices.Subscribe →